Investors are tired of energy transition ‘jam tomorrow’ - FT中文网
登录×
电子邮件/用户名
密码
记住我
请输入邮箱和密码进行绑定操作:
请输入手机号码,通过短信验证(目前仅支持中国大陆地区的手机号):
请您阅读我们的用户注册协议隐私权保护政策,点击下方按钮即视为您接受。
FT商学院

Investors are tired of energy transition ‘jam tomorrow’

Patience is wearing thin, no matter how visionary the strategy
A Johnson Matthey factory in Poland. Excluding disposals, the company’s underlying business has since April 2021 burnt £135mn of cash, on estimates from shareholder Standard Investments

Should fossil fuel and industrial companies spend billions trying to build new, “cleaner” businesses? Or simply squeeze as much cash as possible from existing operations, even if they are in structural decline? This is one of the defining questions of the decade in many sectors.

Successful case studies backing up option A are becoming fewer and farther between. The 207-year-old British industrial group Johnson Matthey’s latest transformation shows how well-meaning ideas can turn into expensive misfires — as well as the dangers of becoming a “jam tomorrow” energy transition stock.

Standard Investments, Johnson Matthey’s largest shareholder, on Monday attacked the group for spending “significant capital” on “unproven” growth businesses. It is not hard to see why the group is coming under pressure: it trades about a fifth lower than rivals on a forward EV/ebitda basis on FactSet data.

Johnson Matthey is known for its catalytic converter business, which is still highly cash generative, despite pressures on the auto sector. Indeed, the company has said the division will generate at least £4.5bn of cash in the decade to 2031, £2bn of which has already been delivered. 

Trouble is, catalytic converters should — over time — become obsolete as consumers switch from combustion engines. Liam Condon, who took over as chief executive in 2022, has hence pursued a strategy which relies, in part, on a bet that other technologies, such as “clean” hydrogen, will take off.

This involves substantial upfront investment. Excluding disposals, Johnson Matthey’s underlying business has since April 1 2021 burnt £135mn of cash, on Standard’s estimates. Growth businesses aren’t solely to blame: Johnson Matthey is also investing in its traditional businesses, including building a more efficient refinery in China for critical materials including platinum.

The hydrogen division — which makes components for fuel cells and electrolysers — has consumed £310mn of cash since the 2022 fiscal year, says Standard. That’s a concern given the clean hydrogen industry is faltering.

Johnson Matthey may be hoping that shareholders will be willing to wait and see. Already, it has taken steps to stabilise the ship. It has delayed the start of production at a UK hydrogen components factory. Overall group capex, which totalled £1.1bn in the past three years, should reduce to £900mn over the next three. Cash flow generation should stabilise, reckons Panmure Liberum’s Lacie Midgley.

The problem is shareholders have already been burnt by Johnson Matthey’s expensive foray into cathodes for electric vehicle batteries under previous management, which resulted in a £363mn impairment and restructuring charge.

As others such as BP know only too well, patience is wearing thin with “cash tomorrow” energy transition promises — no matter how visionary the strategy.

nathalie.thomas@ft.com

版权声明:本文版权归FT中文网所有,未经允许任何单位或个人不得转载,复制或以任何其他方式使用本文全部或部分,侵权必究。

特朗普以“大而美”的政策胜利加强了对权力的控制

美国总统在7月4日庆祝上任数月来取得的一系列成就。

“埃隆终于醒悟”:马斯克努力从特朗普手中拯救特斯拉

世界首富的政治威胁并没有阻止总统的“大而美法案”损害这家电动汽车制造商的利润。

稳定币是如何从小众产品变成普遍战略的?

这种因由美元等现实资产支持而被称为“稳定”的数字货币,已成为美国政府重点关注的项目,也成为企业董事会的热议话题。

工党因福利改革失败内讧

斯塔默放弃了福利改革,这引发了议会内外对斯塔默及其盟友政治判断的怀疑。

美国调低期望寻求达成更有限的贸易协议

总统暂停征收对等关税的90天将于7月9日到期。

美国能源集团斥巨资建造发电厂为数据中心供电

资本支出的增加引发了消费者对能源价格上涨的担忧。
设置字号×
最小
较小
默认
较大
最大
分享×