‘More harmful than helpful’: young people sour on AI - FT中文网
登录×
电子邮件/用户名
密码
记住我
请输入邮箱和密码进行绑定操作:
请输入手机号码,通过短信验证(目前仅支持中国大陆地区的手机号)。如果该手机号尚未注册,将自动创建 FT中文网账号。短信可能需要几分钟送达,验证码15分钟内有效,请耐心等待:
请您阅读我们的用户注册协议和隐私权保护政策,点击下方按钮即视为您接受。
人工智能

‘More harmful than helpful’: young people sour on AI

Gen Z uses the technology more than anyone, but many fear it is weakening their job prospects and creativity
00:00

{"text":[[{"start":7.2,"text":"Young people were promised that artificial intelligence would make them more productive, more creative and more employable. Many now worry it might make them less valuable instead."}],[{"start":18.15,"text":"From software developers who fear being replaced to students who feel AI is hollowing out learning and creativity, a growing number of young adults say the technology is reshaping their lives in unsettling ways."}],[{"start":29.5,"text":"In the US, roughly half of Gen Z — those born between 1997 and 2012 — reported using generative AI at least once a week. Yet 31 per cent said it made them feel angry, up from 22 per cent last year, according to a recent Gallup poll."}],[{"start":46.2,"text":"Those findings were echoed by young people across three continents interviewed by the FT, some of whom declined to give their full name, who described a similar mix of dependence on and frustration with AI."}],[{"start":58.75,"text":"Misha, 24, who recently completed a master’s degree in computing at Imperial College London, said advances in AI had made his coding skills less valuable. “It feels like junior software developers are basically just micromanaging AI at this point,” he said."}],[{"start":74.25,"text":"For many graduates, AI has turned job hunting into an arms race. Applicants use chatbots to generate ever more applications while employers deploy algorithms to sift through the deluge, and candidates find themselves navigating multiple rounds of automated interviews and assessments before ever speaking to a human."}],[{"start":95.05,"text":"A recent study led by researchers from Stanford University found that on one popular “gamified” assessment platform, jobseekers would need to apply for at least 25 different positions to be almost certain of receiving at least one recommendation to proceed to the next stage of an application. Many graduates have described applying to hundreds of positions without having a single job offer."}],[{"start":117.19999999999999,"text":"“The world of job applications is broken”, said Lucy, 24, who works in marketing at a current affairs magazine. She turned to approaching hiring managers in person and sending cold emails in the hopes of being acknowledged by a human."}],[{"start":130.89999999999998,"text":"Céleste Collet, a 21-year-old studying for a dual degree between Sciences Po in Paris and the University of California, Berkeley, said that while she was positive about AI’s potential “huge impact”, she questioned “how many jobs are going to be left in the future”."}],[{"start":146.2,"text":"Collet added she used Anthropic’s Claude chatbot to help structure and research her thesis, though she wrote the paper herself. She had previously “loved” doing the work on her own and felt the chatbot “killed the exercise” but turned to it because of time pressures."}],[{"start":162.2,"text":"Beyond the workplace and the classroom, many complained that AI made it harder to distinguish fact from fiction. Lucy said the spread of AI-generated images has given politicians plausible deniability when compromising footage of them emerges. “When you see an image, that should be able to be used as concrete evidence. It isn’t anymore.”"}],[{"start":181.29999999999998,"text":"“It’s bleeding across all aspects of the media,” she said. “You just don’t know what to trust.”"}],[{"start":188.49999999999997,"text":"Eliza Castell, 25, who works for a British MP, said there had been an increase in politicians using phrases such as “I rise to speak” in the House of Commons, which OpenAI’s ChatGPT often uses when asked to write a speech for parliament."}],[{"start":204.19999999999996,"text":"She said: “There’s this anxiety that if you’re just using AI to do everything, are you not just proving your job can be done by AI?”"}],[{"start":211.44999999999996,"text":"In the US, the backlash against the pace of technological advancement has been seen in university commencement speeches, where graduates have heckled speakers who have extolled AI."}],[{"start":null,"text":"

"}],[{"start":222.09999999999997,"text":"Ex-Google chief executive Eric Schmidt was met with jeers and boos by students at the University of Arizona as he spoke of the technology’s capacity to “touch every profession, every classroom, every hospital, every laboratory, every person and every relationship you have”."}],[{"start":238.94999999999996,"text":"The backlash has spawned movements such as the Luddite Club. Founded in 2021, the group met weekly in Brooklyn’s Prospect Park to read, paint, talk and listen to music, eschewing smartphones in favour of flip phones."}],[{"start":254.19999999999996,"text":"The club has spread across the US and lists on its website chapters at universities and high schools from California to New Jersey, with a branch in Australia and another in Sweden. Members have staged rallies and protests against AI and big tech groups."}],[{"start":270.04999999999995,"text":"Despite their misgivings, many young people use the technology and see its potential. Just one in five Gen Z members surveyed by Gallup said they had never used AI, roughly the same share as in 2025."}],[{"start":284.44999999999993,"text":"Lucy said AI had been a boon for her younger sister, who suffers from issues with her short-term memory following an accident. Each day, she uses a voice-recording tool to turn her recollections into accessible summaries, which Lucy said had been “hugely supportive” and improved her ability to learn."}],[{"start":303.49999999999994,"text":"Soham, 20, an engineering student in Chennai, India, said that use of the technology among his friends is widespread and increasingly acceptable, especially in sending emails. “Earlier people would hide em dashes [a common feature of AI-generated text]. Nowadays people are more unapologetic. People have accepted AI is the norm.”"}],[{"start":324.69999999999993,"text":"Soham feared the impact of AI on India’s vast digital services sector and the legions of tech workers it employs. “The government really doesn’t understand how AI works. There is no department or leg of government actively ensuring it is on the right track.”"}],[{"start":342.44999999999993,"text":"Others complained about AI’s growing intrusion into everyday life. Matthew, 26, a sales representative in Texas, recalled someone telling a group at a birthday party to use a chatbot to write a celebration speech. “It felt like an unnecessary shortcut that took the soul out of things,” he said."}],[{"start":360.8499999999999,"text":"“A lot of people use AI for thinking or creativity and seeing [those skills] disappear from people around me is discouraging . . . I think we’ve gotten to the point where it has become more harmful than helpful.”"}],[{"start":373.0999999999999,"text":"Young people “feel rubbed out”, said Baroness Beeban Kidron, a child safety campaigner and crossbench peer in the UK’s House of Lords."}],[{"start":381.0999999999999,"text":"“They’re being asked to embrace technology while being told there are no jobs, that the machines are taking over and five people in the world will rule the roost. They’re going, where do I go, what do I do, who am I?”"}],[{"start":395.3499999999999,"text":"Data visualisation by Cleve Jones"}],[{"start":405.0999999999999,"text":""}]],"url":"https://audio.ftcn.net.cn/album/a_1780307097_6411.mp3"}

版权声明:本文版权归FT中文网所有,未经允许任何单位或个人不得转载,复制或以任何其他方式使用本文全部或部分,侵权必究。

AI股票泡沫终于要破裂了吗?

马丁:任何理性的人都能看出AI资产中不可持续的迹象。

埃森哲与“四大”瞄准中型企业市场谋增长

随着AI释放人力、降低服务成本,咨询巨头纷纷将目光投向规模较小的企业,希望以更低价格提供服务。

法拉奇:“我从未支持无休止的战争”

英国改革党领导人在美国共和党中期选举惨败后淡化了自己对伊朗战争的支持。

“蓝色浪潮”对美国经济变革的期待恐将落空

艾肯格林:美国国会的党派构成发生变化,对特朗普剩余任期内的政策制定影响不大。

民主党横扫中期选举,华尔街大金主押注失利

顶级对冲基金经理和私募股权投资公司高管为共和党竞选活动投入逾3亿美元,却几乎未见成效。
22小时前

美国的清晨,市场的黄昏

罗奇:美国中期选举结果再令人震惊,也阻止不了经济金融周期的转向。
设置字号×
最小
较小
默认
较大
最大
分享×